Update: I had a chance today to test AutoStitch’s handling of ghosting during Joe’s and my walk through North Beach in San Francisco, where I used my iPhone as the main camera and my DSLR as a backup. In short, AutoStitch falls short with regards to ghosting as you can see in the stitched street scene below. Still, we remain fans of AutoStitch and it retains its Editor’s Pick.
Ghosting issues are clearly visible in the 100% crop from Autostitch
p.s. If you find it unfair to compare AutoStitch to Photoshop, you are right. The two cannot be compared. However, as a photographer, I have a choice: Stitch on my iPhone or stitch back home on my Mac. To me, it’s no question – I stitch at home using Photoshop.
Wow! This one word is hardly enough to describe the performance of AutoStitch, a $1.99 program to stitch panoramas on your iPhone. And it makes me eat my own words that the iPhone is not ready yet for panorama photography.
Check out the difference in exposure in the top two shots. AutoStitch had no problems blending these two as part of a 3x3 matrix panorama
The outcome of several test stitches was excellent. AutoStitch correctly aligned multiple images in horizontal or matrix panoramas without any visible artifacts, unless you did some pixel-peeping. Blending was very good indoors (image on the right) and showed the usual sky blending issues (see image below) in outdoor shots, which is more of an issue with not being able to set exposure on an iPhone 3G than with AutoStitch (this should be better through tap-to-focus/expose on the iPhone 3GS, although only slightly). I have not tested ghosting, but will report back, once I know how AutoStitch deals with it.
Very good stitch, although some blending issues are visible in the sky
Overall, I was amazed by the quality of the stitched images. Given the low quality of the iPhone 3G camera, the output of a Photoshop stitch did not look significantly better than AutoStitch’s. If you do not have Photoshop or do want to stitch on the iPhone, AutoStitch is the app to use!
AutoStitch does have some short-comings, though. I would have liked to see a crop feature, so I could have cropped off the black bars and wiggly lines so typical in raw stitches. However, I could easily crop these stitches in PhotoGene (or Editor’s Pick for Photo Editing); thus, it’s not too much of a shortcoming. And while I could stitch a horizontal (multiple shots in one row) and matrix (many rows by many columns) panorama, I could not stitch a vertical (multiple shots in one column) panorama in AutoStitch (I could only after rotating each shot in PhotoGene before the stitch and then rotating the resulting panorama again in PhotoGene after the stitch was complete). Other than that, AutoStitch exceeded all my expectations.
One additional warning: Stitching is very resource-intensive and thus has quite an impact on battery life and the temperature of your iPhone. But this is true with all panorama stitching apps.
Overall, for the price ($1.99) you get a ton of functionality and great output quality. Which not only earns AutoStitch an easy Editor’s Pick from us, but also leaves the competition with a very high hurdle to overcome!
Price: $1.99 in iTunes
Did you enjoy this article? Please subscribe to iPhonePhotoVideo to receive all the updates on time and for free!
Related posts:
Comments on this entry are closed.